I see where you’re coming from but a young player not ready to break into a PL team compared to a player who can’t muster more than a handful of second rate Spanish league 2 substitute appearances doesn’t bode well.
Nothing new there Richard
Doesn't mean much, BPF couldn't get a game at non league York.Richard wrote: ↑Wed May 16, 2018 7:51 pmI mean the one that struggled to get selected for a Spanish second division team managing 5 appearances or 107 minutes in total, not even making the bench for the last three games and subsequently has been left out the last two Japanese Internationals and might not even make the plane to Russia, that one
Apparently demanded 75k when his move before broke down at villa, so as much as I'd love to see him here, I doubt it will happen
And he isn't good enough for a team that would like to finish top 6, the only reason fans are raving over him is because of how poor Felix and Lonergan are, BPF might be one for the future. If you want to get excited over some Japanese bloke joining and feel he could be the real deal I'm not going to argue with you, he won't ever start a game for Leeds, that's my prediction.
BPF is a good backup (and based on what he showed in the first team, not only a decent keeper in comparison to Lonergan/Wiedwald.). We need an experienced keeper though, no doubt. The better should play.Richard wrote: ↑Thu May 17, 2018 6:44 pmAnd he isn't good enough for a team that would like to finish top 6, the only reason fans are raving over him is because of how poor Felix and Lonergan are, BPF might be one for the future. If you want to get excited over some Japanese bloke joining and feel he could be the real deal I'm not going to argue with you, he won't ever start a game for Leeds, that's my prediction.
I don’t disagree with any of thisfred wrote: ↑Thu May 17, 2018 10:07 pmBPF is a good backup (and based on what he showed in the first team, not only a decent keeper in comparison to Lonergan/Wiedwald.). We need an experienced keeper though, no doubt. The better should play.
The loaned out Japanese guy looks very light-weight. He`s young too, hard to imagine that he will improve the team...probably not a coincidence his fee was only 500`000.
Lonergren is probably he second worst ever keeper at the club IMO . Worst would be Rachubka ,who was so bad he made even Lonergren look ok ( I'd say no better than ok ).Richard wrote: ↑Thu May 17, 2018 6:44 pmAnd he isn't good enough for a team that would like to finish top 6, the only reason fans are raving over him is because of how poor Felix and Lonergan are, BPF might be one for the future. If you want to get excited over some Japanese bloke joining and feel he could be the real deal I'm not going to argue with you, he won't ever start a game for Leeds, that's my prediction.
The present Lonergan is even worse than the other Lonergan we once had some years ago....Clacton White wrote: ↑Sat May 19, 2018 5:51 amLonergren is probably he second worst ever keeper at the club IMO . Worst would be Rachubka ,who was so bad he made even Lonergren look ok ( I'd say no better than ok ).
Thanks very muchnmj1989 wrote: ↑Sat May 12, 2018 9:54 pmPosh fan in peace here!
Wanted to give you a bit of a low down on Marcus as I think he will end up at Leeds over the next couple of months.
It's such a tough one really. He is without doubt the best player we have had here over the past 5 years and we have had some good players.
However, the baggage that he comes with has seemingly put off potential suitors every transfer window.
So here's the pro's:
Every single time MM gets the ball, you feel something special is about to happen.
He is so fluid when he gets on the ball, he's reasonably quick, agile and when he's running at defenders is very hard to stop.
He makes space for himself so easily. Even if the opposition man mark him, he tends to be too good for them and is always available.
He's a great penalty taker. I think he's only missed one since he has been here.
But most of all, he is an assist king. 60 odd assists over 4 seasons, including 22 this year. With the ball at his feet, he will pick out just about anybody who is within 50 yards of him with ease. He spots passes that no other player would even think about.
And now the con's:
The guy is a complete prick. A sulking, cheating spoilt brat. I'll break it down a little more.
If he doesn't get his own way and another player chooses to pass to someone else, he throws his arms around and his head drops straight away. He moans constantly and has a look on his face like someone has murdered his favourite pet.
He's a cheat. No two ways about it. He dives constantly, faigns injury and tries to get opposition players sent off. I'm all for our players going down if they've been fouled, but the majority of our fans are embarrassed when Marcus does it as it is so dramatic. You will hear his squeals from the top tier!
He's not a team player. Whenever we score, he doesnt get involved in the celebrations. Instead he either celebrates by himself, or simply ignores it and slowly walks back to his own half.
He should score more goals. For a player of his quality, he really should score more. He's our main penalty taker and for a guy who played 40 odd games this season, I think he only scored 3 goals that weren't penalties. He also takes every free kick but hasn't scored a direct free kick for almost 3 years.
50 percent of our fans love him, 50 percent think his negatives outweigh his positives and in fact we would be a better, more coherant team without him.
Oh, and he's wears 2 different boots. No idea why.
I firmly believe that if he didn't have so many negatives, he would be in the premier league by now.
Do I think he's worth the risk? Yeah, I do. You could spend 2 or 3 million quid on far, far worse players.
To sum him up:
Supremely talented, but of a tosser.
Hope that helps and good luck next season!
