Player ratings v Newcastle

Predict the scores...if you can!

- LUFC Match Predictions
- Predict Six
- FA Cup Predictions

Plenty to choose from - dip in and have a go - all MOT members welcome. Just for fun.
Post Reply
User avatar
faaip
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 39785
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 am
Location: God's own county

Player ratings v Newcastle

Post by faaip »

Meslier
Dallas
Ayling
Cooper
Firpo
Phillips
Klich
Rodrigo
Raphinha
James
Bamford

subs

Roberts
Summerville
Shackleton
21/22 team - Meslier - Ayling - Firpo- Koch - Llorente - Phillips - Dallas - Raphinha - Harrison - Klich - Rodrigo
User avatar
faaip
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 39785
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 am
Location: God's own county

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by faaip »

Meslier - 8
Dallas - 6
Ayling - 5
Cooper - 5
Firpo - 6.5
Phillips - 8
Klich - 8
Rodrigo - 9
Raphinha - 8.5
James - 8
Bamford - 5.5

subs

Roberts - 6
Summerville - 7.5
Shackleton - N/A
21/22 team - Meslier - Ayling - Firpo- Koch - Llorente - Phillips - Dallas - Raphinha - Harrison - Klich - Rodrigo
Leeds1000
First Team
First Team
Posts: 1587
Joined: Sun Jun 21, 2020 6:11 pm

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by Leeds1000 »

Meslier 7: Kept it 1-1 with at least 2 good saves.

Dallas 3: Looks woefully short in so many ways at the moment. He's not the only one.

Ayling 5: Some ok stuff in possession but mostly poor from Bill at the minute. A mistake waiting to happen and it nearly did with the header at the end.

Cooper 5: If Coops had pace he would have been a top top defender. Got skinned a few times but a couple of very good last ditch challenges at the end there.

Firpo 4: Covid? A couple of good breaks, one where he puts it on a plate for Raph, but christ the rumours about his defending could be true, his close ball control looks atrocious so far.

Phillips 7: Tried his best again, our best outfield player without dictating like last season yet. Its been said, if Kalvin gets injured God help us at the minute.

Klich 5: Better with Klich in there but still not enough creativity after the first 15mins.

Rodrigo 6: Better game although i didn't quite see the Jamie Carragher love in first half. I think JC got carried away with Rod jumping over the ball. Better but imo still not good enough.

Raphinha 5: Extra point for the flukey goal, a couple of moments but nothing match winning. Disappointed with Raph so far in the games i have seen. If he was full of confidence he scores that early chance.

James 4: One to forget for Dan on his debut. Looked a bit overawed or underwhelmed time will tell which.

Bamford 3: Its just not falling for Pads at the minute and he looks terrible for it.

subs

Roberts 3: Didn't see anything that convinced me otherwise. Not a game changer still.

Summerville 5: A couple of decent touches. Its hard coming in at the moment as we have seen with James.
User avatar
wilsdenwhite
Reserve Player
Reserve Player
Posts: 421
Joined: Fri Dec 28, 2018 9:35 am

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by wilsdenwhite »

Meslier 7 - Some great stops

Dallas 6 - Not the best start to the season. Hardly ever see him in and around the box these days. Not his fault.

Ayling 6 - Struggled at times. Kept on his toes when defending.

Cooper 6 - Some good tackles. Like Ayling, barely coped with Maxim at times.

Firpo 4 - Looked very average and clumsy in the tackle. Offering nothing Alioski couldn't so far.

Phillips 6 - Some nice passes as usual but also a fair few poorly executed ones.

Klich 5 - Average start to the season. Think he is either going to go one of two ways now and I think he may lose his place again eventually. Shooting was dreadful when the opportunity arose.

Rodrigo 7 - Looked lively and up for it and worked hard.

Raphina 7 - Pretty average so far, missed a sitter and should've done better a number of times in their box.

James 5 - Very low key start but most things seemed to be going down the other side first half. Never really unleashed.

Bamford 4 - Does look slow at times. Seems to be right back in barn door mode at the moment.

Subs

Roberts 3 - Sick of the sight of him and feel like switching over when I see him coming on. Runs around but final passes, crosses and shots are terrible. Can't understand why he got a new contract. About as dangerous as a money spider.

Summerville 5 - Not a bad start but saw very little of the ball tbf. Happy when I saw the bench and thought finally one of our youngsters might get a chance.
|||L|||E|||E|||D|||S|||
User avatar
Ellandback1
Site Contributor
Site Contributor
Posts: 5517
Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2018 3:01 pm
Twitter: @EllandBack1

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by Ellandback1 »

Meslier - 8. Safe pair of hands. Pulled off two stunning saves

Dallas - 4. A shadow of last season

Ayling - 5. Slightly better than Dallas

Cooper - 4. Made a World class tackle in the second half, but mostly came out second best against the impressive Saint Max. Lacked any kind of Captaincy

Firpo - 2. Hands up, who underestimated Alioski?

Phillips - 8. Solid and dependable

Klich - 7. Had enough long range shots to put the keeper under more pressure. Busy in midfield, without influencing it too much

Rodrigo - 8. Influential, and was a leader on the pitch. The only player to make things happen. Great dummy for the goal.

Raphinha - 7. Fluke of a goal. Some nice touches

James - 6. Got dispossessed too easily

Bamford - 4. Marked out of the game

Subs.

Roberts - 6. Ok

Summerville - 6. Timid. Didn't want to make any mistakes so was ultra safe

Shackleton - 6. Needs more game time


Bielsa - 5. When you know what your opponent is going to do, its easy to outsmart them, a Millwall fan could. Our fan relies heavily on our wing backs. Unfortunately Ayling, Firpo and Dallas have been awful this season but Bielsa prefers to pick his favourites instead of the players in form.
User avatar
Johnboy1965
Reserve Player
Reserve Player
Posts: 270
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2021 7:53 am

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by Johnboy1965 »

Meslier - 8
Dallas - 4
Ayling - 5
Cooper - 6
Firpo - 4
Phillips - 7
Klich - 6
Rodrigo - 7
Raphinha - 6
James - 4
Bamford - 4

subs

Roberts - 4
Summerville - 5
Shackleton - NA
User avatar
1964white
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 97687
Joined: Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:46 am
Twitter: @1964white

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by 1964white »

Thank you Faaip for starting this thread :tup:

8 Meslier
5 Dallas
6 Ayling
6 Cooper
6 Firpo
8 Phillips
7 Klich
8 Rodrigo
8 Raphinha
6 James
4 Bamford
subs
5 Roberts
6 Summerville
n/a Shackleton

Once Raphinha departed our attacking options went flat.
User avatar
Ratscoot
Manager
Manager
Posts: 3051
Joined: Sun Aug 17, 2014 3:52 pm

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle

Post by Ratscoot »

Meslier - 7.5
Dallas - 5
Ayling - 5
Cooper - 6
Firpo - 5
Phillips - 8
Klich - 7
Rodrigo - 7.5
Raphinha - 6.5
James - 5.5
Bamford - 6

subs
Roberts - 4
Summerville - 5
A bumble bee under the laws of physics shouldnt be able to fly, but it does because no one has told it that it can't
Cjay
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 13527
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2017 3:01 pm

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle - Anymore ratings?

Post by Cjay »

Meslier-7
Dallas-4
Ayling-4
Cooper-5
Firpo-4
KP- 7
Raph-7
James-5
Klich-7
Rodrigo-7
Bamford-4

Summerville-5
Roberts-3
Signed

King Cjay

Fountain of all knowledge and wisdom
User avatar
John in Louisiana
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 5946
Joined: Sat Mar 15, 2014 6:09 pm

Re: Player rankings v Newcastle - Anymore ratings?

Post by John in Louisiana »

If it's not too late.........

Meslier - 8
Dallas - 5.5
Ayling - 5.5
Cooper - 6
Firpo - 5.5
Phillips - 7.5
Klich - 6
Rodrigo - 7.5
Raphinha - 6
James - 5.5
Bamford - 5.5

subs

Roberts - 4
Summerville - 5
Shackleton - NA
User avatar
1964white
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 97687
Joined: Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:46 am
Twitter: @1964white

Re: Player ratings v Newcastle

Post by 1964white »

Top 3

7.7 Meslier
7.4 Phillips
7.4 Rodrigo
Post Reply