BBC or ITV pundits...

[1964white]

Who do you prefer

Linekar, Hansen, Lawrenson, Dixon, Shearer

OR

Chiles,Townsend, Keane, Carragher & whoever else they can drag into the studio

Have you notice how Roy Keane says "Listen" in nearly every sentence

BBC for me & every other sports event apart from Horse Racing (CH4 are kings) & Super league (Sky)

[Genghers]

BBC. The ITV commentary irks me as well... Seems to have been loads of games on 3 so far?

[patlufc]

Must admit I prefere sky but out of bbc & itv bbc slightly edge it.

[LUFCRACE]

Always preferred BBC over ITV.

[billie1]

Neither . Only decent panel I can ever remember was the ITV panel for the 1970 world cup ( Dougan , Crerand , Allison , McNab ) . Back then it was fresh and new as a concept and those guys were genuinely interesting and had something to say . Now it's just boring , tedious , claptrap .

[DallasWhite]

You should try ESPN with Alexi Lalas, Michael Ballack & some bloke called Bob, awful stuff. Great to get the games though :mrgreen:

[theleedsmango]

I don't like Keane or Carragher, and I don't rate Chiles as a presenter. So BBC it is.

Linekar is a good presenter, and Shearer and Hansen always know what they are talking about.

[YorkshireSquare]

BBC every time for me.

Think Lee Dixon is a very underrated pundit. They could get rid of Keown though, find him quite patronising.

ITV just annoy me, I liked Chiles as an MOTD presenter but not as the main man. Townsend and Southgate as well, are they seriously the best they can get?

[Gino 1959]

RTE every time!

[YorkshireSquare]

RTE every time!

Do they show the All-Priests Over-75's Five-a-Side Football Championship?

[Gino 1959]

Do they show the All-Priests Over-75's Five-a-Side Football Championship?

It was actually on last night, mate! Brilliant stuff!

Seriously, we get Giles and an often inebriated/angry Eamon Dunphy kept apart by someone like Brady.

[joelufc20]

as bad as it sounds i actually prefer Gary Neville over any pundit ive heard in a long time. he is alot better than any of the cretins on bbc and itv and i especially detest andy townsend

[billie1]

Giles and Dunphy now that I would watch !

[Emsley]

Carragher - Nofink!

[gessa]

Both channels bore the life out of me, BBC panel are eventually going to morph into one, they are all so similar. I don't watch pre game ,half time or post game, neither have had a decent pundit since, Ian Wright,they're both frightened to employ anyone with a pesonality or a decent sense of humour.

[Gino 1959]

Someone needs to get Ron Manager on their panel.

[HarryofOz]

In Australia the commentary teams and pundits are so bad that the only way to watch any sport (football, rugby, rugby league, tennis, golf, athletics, swimming, hockey, cricket and anything else you would care to mention) is with the sound on mute.

[CardiffWhite]

ITV are ******* ****, ITV are ******* ****, ITV are ******* ****, ITV are ******* **** ...

[woodfordwhites]

you just done a meatloaf on me lol

[markolufc]

BBC every time. Chiles needs to climb out of his own ass.