Player Ratings v Newcastle (h)

[velo]

You won't be saying that Velo, once Klaesson has played in our first team

Fair comment Leon,

We need a quality keeper, I'm not knocking Mes, he's been great, but still lacks in some areas, when was the last time we had a good keeper, maybe Robbo?

[The Subhuman]

All keepers make errors, all players make errors but it gets magnified when it's a keeper .. Meslier is gonna be a great for us, we just need to back him. Still 3/4 years away from peak.

[1964white]

All keepers make errors, all players make errors but it gets magnified when it's a keeper .. Meslier is gonna be a great for us, we just need to back him. Still 3/4 years away from peak.

It certainly is magnified.

Meslier made two fantsatic saves at 0-0 & 0-1.

[Johnboy1965]

I watch every game bud, Mes cost us the game, well technically he did, but The ref let them get away with so many 'unsporting' moments, we would still be playing......it's so obvious IMHO that the game is bent
Re James, you are so far off the mark,

That's your opinion but I disagree
Mes made an error fair enough but he made several outstanding saves to keep us in the game.
The fact that we couldn't score against a side who have only kept one clean sheet all season is what cost us- James included.

Regarding James I said when we signed him he was a waste of money.
He's a one trick pony whose only asset is his pace. He has no end product can't cross a ball or finish.

[White Riot]

Meslier 5
Ayling 7
Llorente 6
Struijk 7
Dallas 6
Koch 7
Klich 6
Rodrigo 6
Raphinha 8
Harrison 7
James 5

Gelhardt 6
Roberts 4

[1964white]

Any more ratings folks?

[1964white]

Top 3

1= Raphinha
1= Llorente
3. Ayling