RATE THE REF - Paul Tierney (Match 38: Brentford (A) - Sunday 22/05/22)

For everything Leeds United related and everything not - Have your say... the Marching on Together way!
Forum rules
Please be sure you are acquainted with the forum rules outlined within our FAQs.

Help support the site by using our Amazon Affiliate link when making any purchases from Amazon.
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Simon Hooper (Match 20: Aston Villa (H) - Thursday 10/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

5/10
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Simon Hooper (Match 20: Aston Villa (H) - Thursday 10/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 20 - Simon Hooper (7 scores) - 3.4

Match 1 (Paul Tierney) - 14/08/21: Man Utd (A) 5 v 1 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 2 (Darren England) - 21/08/21: Everton (H) 2 v 2 Draw (2 Leeds and 4 Everton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 3 (Michael Oliver) - 29/08/21: Burnley (A) 1 v 1 Draw (3 Leeds and 4 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 4 (Craig Pawson) - 12/09/21: Liverpool (H) 0 v 3 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Liverpool yellows; 1 red - Struijk)
Match 5 (Mike Dean) - 17/09/21: Newcastle (A) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 6 (Kevin Friend) - 25/09/21: West Ham (H) 1 v 2 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 7 (Simon Hooper) - 02/10/21: Watford (H) 1 v 0 Win (0 Leeds and 3 Watford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 8 (David Coote) - 16/10/21: Southampton (A) 1 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 Southampton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 9 (Robert Jones) - 23/10/21: Wolves (H) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 3 Wolves yellows; 0 reds)
Match 10 (Anthony Taylor) - 31/10/21: Norwich (A) 1 v 2 Win (4 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)
Match 11 (Darren England) - 07/11/21: Leicester (H) 1 v 1 Draw (1 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 12 (Andre Marriner) - 21/11/21: Spurs (A) 2 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 1 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 13 (Craig Pawson) - 27/11/21: Brighton (A) 0 v 0 Draw (3 Leeds and 1 Brighton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 14 (Kevin Friend) - 30/11/21: Crystal Palace (H) 1 v 0 Win (5 Leeds and 3 Palace yellows; 0 reds)
Match 15 (David Coote) - 05/12/21: Brentford (H) 2 v 2 Draw (5 Leeds and 3 Brentford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 16 (Chris Kavanagh) - 11/12/21: Chelsea (A) 3 v 2 Loss (5 Leeds and 2 Chelsea yellows; 0 reds)
Match 17 (Paul Tierney) - 14/12/21: Man City (A) 7 v 0 Hammering (1 Leeds and 1 Man City yellows; 0 reds)
Match 18 (Andre Marriner) - 18/12/21: Arsenal (H) 1 v 4 Loss (3 Leeds and 1 Arsenal yellows; 0 reds)
Match 19 (Michael Oliver) - 23/02/22: Liverpool (A) 6 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 0 Liverpool yellows; 0 reds)
Match 20 (Simon Hooper) - 10/03/22: Aston Villa (H) 0 v 3 Loss (5 Leeds and 3 Villa yellows; 0 reds)
Match 21 (Paul Tierney) - 02/01/22: Burnley (H) 3 v 1 Win (2 Leeds and 1 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 22 (Mike Dean) - 16/01/22: West Ham (A) 2 v 3 Win (2 Leeds and 3 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 23 (Chris Kavanagh) - 22/01/22: Newcastle (H) 0 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 24 (Jarred Gillett) - 09/02/22: Aston Villa (A) 3 v 3 Draw (3 Leeds and 2 Villa yellows; 1 red - Konsa)
Match 25 (Graham Scott) - 12/02/22: Everton (A) 3 v 0 Loss (1 Leeds and 1 Everton yellow; 0 reds)
Match 26 (Paul Tierney) - 20/02/22: Man Utd (H) 2 v 4 Loss (6 Leeds and 3 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 27 (Craig Pawson) - 26/02/22: Spurs (H) 0 v 4 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 28 (David Coote) - 05/03/22: Leicester (A) 1 v 0 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)

2021/22 - Referee Performance League for Leeds Games
1st Craig Pawson....................Brighton (A)........................7.8
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man Utd (A)........................7.5
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man City (A)........................7.5
2nd= Jarred Gillett.................Aston Villa (A)......................7.5
5th= Mike Dean.....................West Ham (A).......................7.2
5th= Graham Scott....................Everton (A).......................7.2
7th David Coote..................Southampton (A)...................7.1
8th Darren England...............Everton (H)..........................6.4
9th Simon Hooper..................Watford (H).........................6.2
10th Mike Dean....................Newcastle(A).........................6.1
11th= Paul Tierney..................Burnley (H).........................5.6
11th= Kevin Friend..............Crystal Palace (H)..................5.6
13th David Coote..................Leicester (A).........................5.0
14th Kevin Friend...................West Ham (H).....................4.8
15th Michael Oliver ................Burnley (A).........................4.7
16th Darren England..............Leicester (H).......................4.1
17th Anthony Taylor...............Norwich (A)........................4.0
18th= Chris Kavanagh...........Newcastle (H).....................3.4
18th= Simon Hooper..............Aston Villa (H)....................3.4
20th= Craig Pawson................Liverpool (H)......................3.2
20th= Robert Jones...................Wolves (H)........................3.2
22nd Andre Marriner...............Spurs (A)...........................2.8
23rd= Andre Marriner.............Arsenal (H)........................2.7
23rd= Craig Pawson.................Spurs (H)..........................2.7
25th David Coote....................Brentford (H).....................2.3
26th Chris Kavanagh..............Chelsea (A).........................1.6
27th Paul Tierney ...................Man Utd (H).......................1.4
28th Michael Oliver ...............Liverpool (A).......................0.3
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

RATE THE REF - Stuart Atwell (Match 29: Norwich City (H) - Sunday 13/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 29 - Norwich City (H) Sunday 13/03/22

Score: Leeds 2 v 1 Norwich City

Cards:
Red - 0
Yellow - 4 (Leeds: 3 Ayling, James, Harrison: Norwich City: 1 Aarons)

Score out of 10 for today's ref - Stuart Atwell
User avatar
velo
First Team
First Team
Posts: 1988
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2021 2:06 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Stuart Atwell (Match 29: Norwich City (H) - Sunday 13/03/22)

Post by velo »

3
Let the play flow, until we got an advantage, gave the pen, that VAR over turned, everyone saw he fall over Aylings foot, but him
Aarons got away with murder,
Marsching on !
User avatar
Johnboy1965
Subs Bench
Subs Bench
Posts: 724
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2021 7:53 am

Re: RATE THE REF - Stuart Atwell (Match 29: Norwich City (H) - Sunday 13/03/22)

Post by Johnboy1965 »

Too lenient to start with which then led him to give out yellows that previously he would have let go.
Very Inconsistent

3
User avatar
Byebyegeegee
First Team
First Team
Posts: 1435
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2020 5:14 pm
Location: God’s own county (north)

Re: RATE THE REF - Stuart Atwell (Match 29: Norwich City (H) - Sunday 13/03/22)

Post by Byebyegeegee »

Not the worst refereeing performance by any means but with the usual inconsistencies of standards regarding bookable offences, as usual to our detriment. Also VAR saved him from making an error with the penalty decision but, as I’ve said previously and to be fair to him, it would have been difficult to assess in real time, and that is what VAR is for anyway.

He got the game defining “not interfering with play” decision correct imo, judging by current interpretations of that rule. But if that goal had been disallowed compared to Lanzini’s (West Ham’s) goal which had been given then there would and should have been uproar. But, as I say he got it right, so 5.5/10.
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Stuart Atwell (Match 29: Norwich City (H) - Sunday 13/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

6/10
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Stuart Atwell (Match 29: Norwich City (H) - Sunday 13/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 29 - Stuart Atwell (only 4 scores) - 4.4

Match 1 (Paul Tierney) - 14/08/21: Man Utd (A) 5 v 1 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 2 (Darren England) - 21/08/21: Everton (H) 2 v 2 Draw (2 Leeds and 4 Everton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 3 (Michael Oliver) - 29/08/21: Burnley (A) 1 v 1 Draw (3 Leeds and 4 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 4 (Craig Pawson) - 12/09/21: Liverpool (H) 0 v 3 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Liverpool yellows; 1 red - Struijk)
Match 5 (Mike Dean) - 17/09/21: Newcastle (A) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 6 (Kevin Friend) - 25/09/21: West Ham (H) 1 v 2 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 7 (Simon Hooper) - 02/10/21: Watford (H) 1 v 0 Win (0 Leeds and 3 Watford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 8 (David Coote) - 16/10/21: Southampton (A) 1 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 Southampton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 9 (Robert Jones) - 23/10/21: Wolves (H) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 3 Wolves yellows; 0 reds)
Match 10 (Anthony Taylor) - 31/10/21: Norwich (A) 1 v 2 Win (4 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)
Match 11 (Darren England) - 07/11/21: Leicester (H) 1 v 1 Draw (1 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 12 (Andre Marriner) - 21/11/21: Spurs (A) 2 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 1 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 13 (Craig Pawson) - 27/11/21: Brighton (A) 0 v 0 Draw (3 Leeds and 1 Brighton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 14 (Kevin Friend) - 30/11/21: Crystal Palace (H) 1 v 0 Win (5 Leeds and 3 Palace yellows; 0 reds)
Match 15 (David Coote) - 05/12/21: Brentford (H) 2 v 2 Draw (5 Leeds and 3 Brentford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 16 (Chris Kavanagh) - 11/12/21: Chelsea (A) 3 v 2 Loss (5 Leeds and 2 Chelsea yellows; 0 reds)
Match 17 (Paul Tierney) - 14/12/21: Man City (A) 7 v 0 Hammering (1 Leeds and 1 Man City yellows; 0 reds)
Match 18 (Andre Marriner) - 18/12/21: Arsenal (H) 1 v 4 Loss (3 Leeds and 1 Arsenal yellows; 0 reds)
Match 19 (Michael Oliver) - 23/02/22: Liverpool (A) 6 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 0 Liverpool yellows; 0 reds)
Match 20 (Simon Hooper) - 10/03/22: Aston Villa (H) 0 v 3 Loss (5 Leeds and 3 Villa yellows; 0 reds)
Match 21 (Paul Tierney) - 02/01/22: Burnley (H) 3 v 1 Win (2 Leeds and 1 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 22 (Mike Dean) - 16/01/22: West Ham (A) 2 v 3 Win (2 Leeds and 3 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 23 (Chris Kavanagh) - 22/01/22: Newcastle (H) 0 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 24 (Jarred Gillett) - 09/02/22: Aston Villa (A) 3 v 3 Draw (3 Leeds and 2 Villa yellows; 1 red - Konsa)
Match 25 (Graham Scott) - 12/02/22: Everton (A) 3 v 0 Loss (1 Leeds and 1 Everton yellow; 0 reds)
Match 26 (Paul Tierney) - 20/02/22: Man Utd (H) 2 v 4 Loss (6 Leeds and 3 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 27 (Craig Pawson) - 26/02/22: Spurs (H) 0 v 4 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 28 (David Coote) - 05/03/22: Leicester (A) 1 v 0 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 29 (Stuart Atwell) - 13/03/22: Norwich (H) 2 v 1 Win (3 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)

2021/22 - Referee Performance League for Leeds Games
1st Craig Pawson....................Brighton (A)........................7.8
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man Utd (A)........................7.5
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man City (A)........................7.5
2nd= Jarred Gillett.................Aston Villa (A)......................7.5
5th= Mike Dean.....................West Ham (A).......................7.2
5th= Graham Scott....................Everton (A).......................7.2
7th David Coote..................Southampton (A)...................7.1
8th Darren England...............Everton (H)..........................6.4
9th Simon Hooper..................Watford (H).........................6.2
10th Mike Dean....................Newcastle(A).........................6.1
11th= Paul Tierney..................Burnley (H).........................5.6
11th= Kevin Friend..............Crystal Palace (H)..................5.6
13th David Coote..................Leicester (A).........................5.0
14th Kevin Friend...................West Ham (H).....................4.8
15th Michael Oliver ................Burnley (A).........................4.7
16th Stuart Atwell...................Norwich (H)........................4.4
17th Darren England..............Leicester (H).......................4.1
18th Anthony Taylor...............Norwich (A)........................4.0
19th= Chris Kavanagh...........Newcastle (H).....................3.4
19th= Simon Hooper..............Aston Villa (H)....................3.4
21st= Craig Pawson................Liverpool (H)......................3.2
21st= Robert Jones...................Wolves (H)........................3.2
23rd Andre Marriner...............Spurs (A)...........................2.8
24th= Andre Marriner.............Arsenal (H)........................2.7
24th= Craig Pawson.................Spurs (H)..........................2.7
26th David Coote....................Brentford (H).....................2.3
27th Chris Kavanagh..............Chelsea (A).........................1.6
28th Paul Tierney ...................Man Utd (H).......................1.4
29th Michael Oliver ...............Liverpool (A).......................0.3
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 30 - Wolves (A) Friday 18/03/22

Score: Wolves 2 v 3 Leeds

Cards:
Red - 1 (Wolves: Jimenez)
Yellow - 7 (Leeds: 5 Struijk, Forshaw, Rodrigo, Kenneh, Cresswell: Wolves: 2 Jimenez, Boly)

Score out of 10 for today's ref - Kevin Friend

(previously had for the Home games with Palace and West Ham - sits mid-table on ratings)
User avatar
Byebyegeegee
First Team
First Team
Posts: 1435
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2020 5:14 pm
Location: God’s own county (north)

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Byebyegeegee »

Never been a friend before but probably is tonight. The sending off that completely changed the game was a little harsh imo but we’ll take it - thank you!

Not being used to such favourable decisions from referees, it makes me slightly suspicious that there is an agenda afoot to keep us in the Premier League because of our attractive style of play. Every game we play these days is utterly compelling - but enough of such conspiracy theories, it might just be that things are evening up. Any which way our friend Friend deserves an 8/10.
User avatar
Lorimer46
Subs Bench
Subs Bench
Posts: 863
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2020 12:22 pm
Twitter: @dsc67
Location: Tweedbank, Scottish Borders

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Lorimer46 »

7/10 one of the better refereeing performances this season, when the 50/50 calls go your way I guess it makes all the difference
" The best laid schemes o' mice an' men
Gang aft agley "
User avatar
White Riot
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 9532
Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2019 2:02 pm
Location: Plovdiv, Bulgaria

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by White Riot »

5

Patchy performance. Jimenez should have been booked multiple times before he was booked for his diving and cheating. Should already have been off for me.

The booking for the Meslier challenge was harsh.

Turned his back on Dallas when that should have been a red card.

Let Wolves away with diving, cheating and time wasting all night.

But sending Jimenez off turned the match completely.
User avatar
1964white
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 107076
Joined: Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:46 am
Twitter: @1964white

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by 1964white »

White Riot wrote: Sat Mar 19, 2022 6:05 am 5

Patchy performance. Jimenez should have been booked multiple times before he was booked for his diving and cheating. Should already have been off for me.

The booking for the Meslier challenge was harsh.

Turned his back on Dallas when that should have been a red card.

Let Wolves away with diving, cheating and time wasting all night.

But sending Jimenez off turned the match completely.
Agree James :tup:

6/10
User avatar
Ratscoot
Manager
Manager
Posts: 3252
Joined: Sun Aug 17, 2014 3:52 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Ratscoot »

6/10 good in sections of the game but not great in others, I think he got the sending off right if Spiderboy hadn’t got the ball or Raul got it first then Spiderboy would have at least got a booking so it’s got to work the same for the striker. Plus how many times have we seen Raul leave one in a tackle and get away with it so I don’t feel sorry for him.

My big big bear is the time wasting, I’d said before the game that they’d do it and what a shock once they’d scored players started going down, taking forever over throw ins free kicks etc... the Prem need to do something about it, it’s openly cheating and it bugs the f**k out of me :rant:

I did love it towards the end of the game when we time wasted and their fans started booing :lol:
A bumble bee under the laws of physics shouldnt be able to fly, but it does because no one has told it that it can't
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9311
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

7.5/10
Currie14
Youth Team
Youth Team
Posts: 170
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2019 10:46 am

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Currie14 »

Their second goal came from an unpunished simulation by Jimenez who should already have been off for the dreadful lunge which he only got booked for which would've rendered the mes challenge irrelevant. The challenge on Dallas was also a red & he missed that one too.
With regards to the big lump tackling himself & Struijk (Who was atrocious again) getting a yellow for it leading to their goal, what exactly is the point of VAR & why can't they look at whether the free kick was merited and disallow the goal?

5.0 for at least not being biased.
User avatar
weasel
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 9406
Joined: Wed May 23, 2007 10:28 pm
Location: Within a mile of Yorkshire

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by weasel »

Can't give him a score as didn't watch the full match but can't see why some experts are suggesting the sending off was harsh. It may have been harsh if it had been a straight red but it wasn't. It was a straightforward late tackle that resulted in injury. Messlier clearly got to the ball first and as such the Wolves player is late.

Looks like he missed the challenge on Dallas which was nasty.
Marsching on Together

Jesse Marsch is taking us down under!
User avatar
faaip
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 42825
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 am
Location: God's own county

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by faaip »

Has to be a 10, we got just about everything and for once on the right side of a dodgy ref performance... Maybe word has filtered down from on high now Bielsa has gone (who the EPL must have hated with his refusal to speak English and high sense of ethics) they need LUFC in the PL... We'll start to get more decisions
1 - Revie
2 - Bielsa
3 - Wilkinson

THE LEEDS LEGENDS ... never to be forgotten

THE LAST REAMINING ORTA/RADS FAN
User avatar
velo
First Team
First Team
Posts: 1988
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2021 2:06 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by velo »

3, as said he let Jiminez get away with far too much and Saiz too, they should have been down to 9,
Marsching on !
danhirons
Manager
Manager
Posts: 2929
Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2014 11:21 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by danhirons »

10 for giving every decision to us

5 based on how accurate most of his decisions were
Post Reply