RATE THE REF - Paul Tierney (Match 38: Brentford (A) - Sunday 22/05/22)

For everything Leeds United related and everything not - Have your say... the Marching on Together way!
Forum rules
Please be sure you are acquainted with the forum rules outlined within our FAQs.

Help support the site by using our Amazon Affiliate link when making any purchases from Amazon.
Cjay
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 17311
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2017 3:01 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Cjay »

5

I think he was maybe a bit lenient at times.

The Jimenez thing for me is very simple.

If the roles were reversed, exactly the same scenario but Jimenez got there first, no malice from either player but Meslier was late.

Meslier 100% gets booked at the very least.

So surely it has to be the same for the striker?
Signed

King Cjay

Fountain of all knowledge and wisdom
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Any more ?
User avatar
mentalcase
First Team
First Team
Posts: 2284
Joined: Sun Aug 08, 2021 3:19 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by mentalcase »

4/10
5 United players booked !!
Don't really know what catergorises a booking any longer, the rules are pathetic, mouthinho should have got a red for the tackle on Dallas but got away scott free.
One of the reasons I started a 'rule change thread'
Keep Fighting
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

danhirons wrote: Sat Mar 19, 2022 12:42 pm 10 for giving every decision to us

5 based on how accurate most of his decisions were
On that basis Dan, I've assumed you've gone 7.5 when working the total out :tup:
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Kevin Friend (Match 30: Wolves (A) - Friday 18/03/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 30 - Kevin Friend (12 scores) - 6.2

Match 1 (Paul Tierney) - 14/08/21: Man Utd (A) 5 v 1 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 2 (Darren England) - 21/08/21: Everton (H) 2 v 2 Draw (2 Leeds and 4 Everton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 3 (Michael Oliver) - 29/08/21: Burnley (A) 1 v 1 Draw (3 Leeds and 4 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 4 (Craig Pawson) - 12/09/21: Liverpool (H) 0 v 3 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Liverpool yellows; 1 red - Struijk)
Match 5 (Mike Dean) - 17/09/21: Newcastle (A) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 6 (Kevin Friend) - 25/09/21: West Ham (H) 1 v 2 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 7 (Simon Hooper) - 02/10/21: Watford (H) 1 v 0 Win (0 Leeds and 3 Watford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 8 (David Coote) - 16/10/21: Southampton (A) 1 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 Southampton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 9 (Robert Jones) - 23/10/21: Wolves (H) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 3 Wolves yellows; 0 reds)
Match 10 (Anthony Taylor) - 31/10/21: Norwich (A) 1 v 2 Win (4 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)
Match 11 (Darren England) - 07/11/21: Leicester (H) 1 v 1 Draw (1 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 12 (Andre Marriner) - 21/11/21: Spurs (A) 2 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 1 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 13 (Craig Pawson) - 27/11/21: Brighton (A) 0 v 0 Draw (3 Leeds and 1 Brighton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 14 (Kevin Friend) - 30/11/21: Crystal Palace (H) 1 v 0 Win (5 Leeds and 3 Palace yellows; 0 reds)
Match 15 (David Coote) - 05/12/21: Brentford (H) 2 v 2 Draw (5 Leeds and 3 Brentford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 16 (Chris Kavanagh) - 11/12/21: Chelsea (A) 3 v 2 Loss (5 Leeds and 2 Chelsea yellows; 0 reds)
Match 17 (Paul Tierney) - 14/12/21: Man City (A) 7 v 0 Hammering (1 Leeds and 1 Man City yellows; 0 reds)
Match 18 (Andre Marriner) - 18/12/21: Arsenal (H) 1 v 4 Loss (3 Leeds and 1 Arsenal yellows; 0 reds)
Match 19 (Michael Oliver) - 23/02/22: Liverpool (A) 6 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 0 Liverpool yellows; 0 reds)
Match 20 (Simon Hooper) - 10/03/22: Aston Villa (H) 0 v 3 Loss (5 Leeds and 3 Villa yellows; 0 reds)
Match 21 (Paul Tierney) - 02/01/22: Burnley (H) 3 v 1 Win (2 Leeds and 1 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 22 (Mike Dean) - 16/01/22: West Ham (A) 2 v 3 Win (2 Leeds and 3 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 23 (Chris Kavanagh) - 22/01/22: Newcastle (H) 0 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 24 (Jarred Gillett) - 09/02/22: Aston Villa (A) 3 v 3 Draw (3 Leeds and 2 Villa yellows; 1 red - Konsa)
Match 25 (Graham Scott) - 12/02/22: Everton (A) 3 v 0 Loss (1 Leeds and 1 Everton yellow; 0 reds)
Match 26 (Paul Tierney) - 20/02/22: Man Utd (H) 2 v 4 Loss (6 Leeds and 3 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 27 (Craig Pawson) - 26/02/22: Spurs (H) 0 v 4 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 28 (David Coote) - 05/03/22: Leicester (A) 1 v 0 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 29 (Stuart Atwell) - 13/03/22: Norwich (H) 2 v 1 Win (3 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)
Match 30 (Kevin Friend) - 18/03/22: Wolves (A) 2 v 3 Win (5 Leeds and 2 Wolves yellows; 1 red - Jimenez)

2021/22 - Referee Performance League for Leeds Games
1st Craig Pawson....................Brighton (A)........................7.8
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man Utd (A)........................7.5
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man City (A)........................7.5
2nd= Jarred Gillett.................Aston Villa (A)......................7.5
5th= Mike Dean.....................West Ham (A).......................7.2
5th= Graham Scott....................Everton (A).......................7.2
7th David Coote..................Southampton (A)...................7.1
8th Darren England...............Everton (H)..........................6.4
9th= Simon Hooper................Watford (H).........................6.2
9th= Kevin Friend ...................Wolves (A)..........................6.2
11th Mike Dean......................Newcastle(A).......................6.1
12th= Paul Tierney..................Burnley (H).........................5.6
12th= Kevin Friend..............Crystal Palace (H)..................5.6
14th David Coote..................Leicester (A).........................5.0
15th Kevin Friend...................West Ham (H).....................4.8
16th Michael Oliver ................Burnley (A).........................4.7
17th Stuart Atwell...................Norwich (H)........................4.4
18th Darren England..............Leicester (H).......................4.1
19th Anthony Taylor................Norwich (A)........................4.0
20th= Chris Kavanagh...........Newcastle (H).....................3.4
20th= Simon Hooper..............Aston Villa (H)....................3.4
22nd= Craig Pawson................Liverpool (H)....................3.2
22nd= Robert Jones...................Wolves (H).......................3.2
24th Andre Marriner................Spurs (A)...........................2.8
25th= Andre Marriner.............Arsenal (H)........................2.7
25th= Craig Pawson.................Spurs (H)..........................2.7
27th David Coote....................Brentford (H).....................2.3
28th Chris Kavanagh..............Chelsea (A).........................1.6
29th Paul Tierney ...................Man Utd (H).......................1.4
30th Michael Oliver ...............Liverpool (A).......................0.3
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 31 - Southampton (H) Saturday 02/04/22

Score: Leeds 1 v 1 Southampton

Cards:
Red - 0
Yellow - 2 (Leeds: 1 Ayling; Southampton: 1 Elyounoussi)

Score out of 10 for today's ref - Anthony Taylor

(previously only seen away at Norwich, back in Oct in match week 10 - a performance which him awarded a score of 4.0)
User avatar
velo
First Team
First Team
Posts: 2016
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2021 2:06 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by velo »

I'll be generous and give him 3, he was colour blind, couldn't see what Wp was doing/diving
Marsching on !
User avatar
Johnboy1965
Subs Bench
Subs Bench
Posts: 730
Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2021 7:53 am

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by Johnboy1965 »

Overall not a bad performance.
Let the game flow when he could.
Got all the big decisions correct.

7
foxy
Ballboy
Ballboy
Posts: 17
Joined: Sun Nov 28, 2021 10:42 am

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by foxy »

cracking first half was helped by way he let the game flow and accepted physical contact by both sides. could have given us a penalty when joffy was brought down near the end so loses a point. 6
User avatar
1964white
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 107336
Joined: Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:46 am
Twitter: @1964white

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by 1964white »

6/10
User avatar
Kennyb41
First Team
First Team
Posts: 2008
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2022 10:15 am

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by Kennyb41 »

This guy was spot on from start to finish, i'd have him every week no problem, continually let the game flow, fell for no shite and kept up with play well 9/10.

Way too many here have rose tinted leeds specs on, it's no wonder we get shite from refs, and they wonder why.
A self-confessed lover of Bigots, Walts, Otters and Dandelions.
Must dash.
8-)
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Didn’t see full game, but based on the highlights 7.5/10
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

Re: RATE THE REF - Anthony Taylor (Match 31: Southampton (H) - Saturday 02/04/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 31- Anthony Taylor (6 scores) - 6.4

Match 1 (Paul Tierney) - 14/08/21: Man Utd (A) 5 v 1 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 2 (Darren England) - 21/08/21: Everton (H) 2 v 2 Draw (2 Leeds and 4 Everton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 3 (Michael Oliver) - 29/08/21: Burnley (A) 1 v 1 Draw (3 Leeds and 4 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 4 (Craig Pawson) - 12/09/21: Liverpool (H) 0 v 3 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Liverpool yellows; 1 red - Struijk)
Match 5 (Mike Dean) - 17/09/21: Newcastle (A) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 6 (Kevin Friend) - 25/09/21: West Ham (H) 1 v 2 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 7 (Simon Hooper) - 02/10/21: Watford (H) 1 v 0 Win (0 Leeds and 3 Watford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 8 (David Coote) - 16/10/21: Southampton (A) 1 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 2 Southampton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 9 (Robert Jones) - 23/10/21: Wolves (H) 1 v 1 Draw (2 Leeds and 3 Wolves yellows; 0 reds)
Match 10 (Anthony Taylor) - 31/10/21: Norwich (A) 1 v 2 Win (4 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)
Match 11 (Darren England) - 07/11/21: Leicester (H) 1 v 1 Draw (1 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 12 (Andre Marriner) - 21/11/21: Spurs (A) 2 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 1 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 13 (Craig Pawson) - 27/11/21: Brighton (A) 0 v 0 Draw (3 Leeds and 1 Brighton yellows; 0 reds)
Match 14 (Kevin Friend) - 30/11/21: Crystal Palace (H) 1 v 0 Win (5 Leeds and 3 Palace yellows; 0 reds)
Match 15 (David Coote) - 05/12/21: Brentford (H) 2 v 2 Draw (5 Leeds and 3 Brentford yellows; 0 reds)
Match 16 (Chris Kavanagh) - 11/12/21: Chelsea (A) 3 v 2 Loss (5 Leeds and 2 Chelsea yellows; 0 reds)
Match 17 (Paul Tierney) - 14/12/21: Man City (A) 7 v 0 Hammering (1 Leeds and 1 Man City yellows; 0 reds)
Match 18 (Andre Marriner) - 18/12/21: Arsenal (H) 1 v 4 Loss (3 Leeds and 1 Arsenal yellows; 0 reds)
Match 19 (Michael Oliver) - 23/02/22: Liverpool (A) 6 v 0 Loss (3 Leeds and 0 Liverpool yellows; 0 reds)
Match 20 (Simon Hooper) - 10/03/22: Aston Villa (H) 0 v 3 Loss (5 Leeds and 3 Villa yellows; 0 reds)
Match 21 (Paul Tierney) - 02/01/22: Burnley (H) 3 v 1 Win (2 Leeds and 1 Burnley yellows; 0 reds)
Match 22 (Mike Dean) - 16/01/22: West Ham (A) 2 v 3 Win (2 Leeds and 3 West Ham yellows; 0 reds)
Match 23 (Chris Kavanagh) - 22/01/22: Newcastle (H) 0 v 1 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Newcastle yellows; 0 reds)
Match 24 (Jarred Gillett) - 09/02/22: Aston Villa (A) 3 v 3 Draw (3 Leeds and 2 Villa yellows; 1 red - Konsa)
Match 25 (Graham Scott) - 12/02/22: Everton (A) 3 v 0 Loss (1 Leeds and 1 Everton yellow; 0 reds)
Match 26 (Paul Tierney) - 20/02/22: Man Utd (H) 2 v 4 Loss (6 Leeds and 3 Man Utd yellows; 0 reds)
Match 27 (Craig Pawson) - 26/02/22: Spurs (H) 0 v 4 Loss (4 Leeds and 2 Spurs yellows; 0 reds)
Match 28 (David Coote) - 05/03/22: Leicester (A) 1 v 0 Loss (2 Leeds and 1 Leicester yellows; 0 reds)
Match 29 (Stuart Atwell) - 13/03/22: Norwich (H) 2 v 1 Win (3 Leeds and 1 Norwich yellows; 0 reds)
Match 30 (Kevin Friend) - 18/03/22: Wolves (A) 2 v 3 Win (5 Leeds and 2 Wolves yellows; 1 red - Jimenez)
Match 31 (Anthony Taylor) - 02/04/22: Southampton (H) 1 v 1 Draw (1 Leeds and 1 Southampton yellows; 0 reds)

2021/22 - Referee Performance League for Leeds Games
1st Craig Pawson....................Brighton (A)........................7.8
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man Utd (A)........................7.5
2nd= Paul Tierney...................Man City (A)........................7.5
2nd= Jarred Gillett.................Aston Villa (A)......................7.5
5th= Mike Dean.....................West Ham (A).......................7.2
5th= Graham Scott....................Everton (A).......................7.2
7th David Coote..................Southampton (A)...................7.1
8th= Darren England.............Everton (H)..........................6.4
8th= Anthony Taylor..........Southampton (H)....................6.4
10th= Simon Hooper..............Watford (H).........................6.2
10th= Kevin Friend .................Wolves (A)..........................6.2
12th Mike Dean......................Newcastle(A).......................6.1
13th= Paul Tierney..................Burnley (H).........................5.6
13th= Kevin Friend..............Crystal Palace (H)..................5.6
15th David Coote..................Leicester (A).........................5.0
16th Kevin Friend...................West Ham (H).....................4.8
17th Michael Oliver ................Burnley (A).........................4.7
18th Stuart Atwell...................Norwich (H)........................4.4
19th Darren England..............Leicester (H).......................4.1
20th Anthony Taylor................Norwich (A)........................4.0
21st= Chris Kavanagh............Newcastle (H).....................3.4
21st= Simon Hooper...............Aston Villa (H)....................3.4
23rd= Craig Pawson.................Liverpool (H)....................3.2
23rd= Robert Jones....................Wolves (H).......................3.2
25th Andre Marriner.................Spurs (A)...........................2.8
26th= Andre Marriner..............Arsenal (H)........................2.7
26th= Craig Pawson..................Spurs (H)..........................2.7
28th David Coote....................Brentford (H).....................2.3
29th Chris Kavanagh..............Chelsea (A).........................1.6
30th Paul Tierney ...................Man Utd (H).......................1.4
31st Michael Oliver ...............Liverpool (A).......................0.3
User avatar
Muppet the Cat
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9360
Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
Location: Cardiff

RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by Muppet the Cat »

Match 32 - Watford (A) Saturday 09/04/22

Score: Watford 0 v 3 Leeds

Cards:
Red - 0
Yellow - 2 (Leeds: 0 :shock: :shock: :shock: ; Watford: 2 Louza, Sissoko)

Score out of 10 for today's ref - Andre Marriner
User avatar
weasel
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 9458
Joined: Wed May 23, 2007 10:28 pm
Location: Within a mile of Yorkshire

Re: RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by weasel »

Thought the ref was very whistle happy, preferred the ref the other week wholet the game flow more. Don't recall him getting any major deicisons though he should have booked the Watford player who hauled Dam James to the floor to stop us breaking away. Amazed that we picked up no bookings as I felt we didn't play any differently than we have all season yet get bookings for nothing. 7/10
Marsching on Together

Jesse Marsch is taking us down under!
User avatar
velo
First Team
First Team
Posts: 2016
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2021 2:06 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by velo »

5, gave them a fk every time they fell over, and they did lot, Kuco should have had 2 yellows at least, but as ever the cheats just get away with it week in week out
Marsching on !
User avatar
Byebyegeegee
First Team
First Team
Posts: 1454
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2020 5:14 pm
Location: God’s own county (north)

Re: RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by Byebyegeegee »

4. Nothing major but just terribly inconsistent with what constituted a free kick and what didn’t and seemed to give Watford the benefit of the doubt more often than not, maybe because they were the home team or maybe because we’re Leeds United, I don’t know - very frustrating!
User avatar
faaip
Superstar
Superstar
Posts: 42982
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 am
Location: God's own county

Re: RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by faaip »

4, sub par performance, probably for both teams
1 - Revie
2 - Bielsa
3 - Wilkinson

THE LEEDS LEGENDS ... never to be forgotten

THE LAST REAMINING ORTA/RADS FAN
User avatar
Kennyb41
First Team
First Team
Posts: 2008
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2022 10:15 am

Re: RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by Kennyb41 »

I didn't see much wrong 7/10.
A self-confessed lover of Bigots, Walts, Otters and Dandelions.
Must dash.
8-)
User avatar
Ratscoot
Manager
Manager
Posts: 3255
Joined: Sun Aug 17, 2014 3:52 pm

Re: RATE THE REF - Andre Marriner (Match 32: Watford (A) - Saturday 09/04/22)

Post by Ratscoot »

5 it was a poor game and I don’t think the officials helped, they weren’t bias towards either team equally awful to both
A bumble bee under the laws of physics shouldnt be able to fly, but it does because no one has told it that it can't
Post Reply