Illan Meslier poll

[1964white]

Please make a comment posting up your preferred option, not forgetting to use the vote tab at the top of each of our players polls.

[Johnthewhite]

Move him on, he has had more than enough time to progress and not done enough for me.
The lads a giant but plays like a kid in the street at times, unsettles the back line.

[Clacton White]

Not good enough imo . Always a mistake or two in him , don't have any faith in him and when his confidence goes ........

[Sean_Nile]

Having a deep voice didn't make you a man or a goalkeeper

[Barlow Boy]

I’ve mentioned it several times.

He’s a decent enough young keeper, pulls out some important saves (Leicester, Norwich to name just two) but this talk of we’ve got a £30M to £40M goalkeeper on our hands is pie in the sky for me.

£20M and I’d move him on.

[Carrick Dave]

Like Barlow, I’d start again with the right offer. If he stays, I’d like to see them bring someone in who will properly contest the number 1 spot and keep him at the top of his game.

[The Subhuman]

Keep for me...

[Orange Box]

Not the best shot-stopper anymore. Uselessly flaps at corners. Doesn’t know how to catch under pressure. See what offers come in - I doubt we’ll be talking big numbers.

[Tyzy]

It's time to for him to go,he doesn't seem to be improving having said that he's saved us from defeat a few times, this season question is who do you replace him with ?

[John in Louisiana]

Not perfect by any stretch, but where are we going to get a better keeper at this level?

If someone wants to offer mad money for him let him go, but absent a ridiculous offer we should keep him.

[Onemanstanding]

I voted to keep, but not fussed either way, as he doesn't command the box, but makes crucial saves also.
So 50/50 for me.

[1964white]

I voted to keep, but not fussed either way, as he doesn't command the box, but makes crucial saves also.
So 50/50 for me.

I'm in the same mindset.

I only think Mes will move on if a bid comes in from a European club.

So a tentative keep for me.

[Leeds1000]

Keep for me unless we get a substantial offer and or he wants to go. Still only young and learning. Needs to command his box more and be braver but after the last couple of years i thought he bounced back well with the golden glove accolade . Would have been even better had it not been for the International break.

I can think of more pressing positions to fill.

[weasel]

A decent bid and I'd sell. Like others have said I don't think there has been much improvement over the years that he has been here. Still talking about potential. As I mentioned elsewhere McCarthy is out of contract and I feel a move for him would be a good idea.

[andrewjohnsmith]

Definitely keep him. Touted by top league clubs for 2 or 3 years. Still young and will improve.

[Barlow Boy]

Definitely keep him. Touted by top league clubs for 2 or 3 years. Still young and will improve.

But no offers ?.

[Lorimer46]

I'd keep him, but it's dependent on who we sign over the summer. Would he be prepared to be a No2 ?

[Jimang]

I think Meslier had a good season for us, not many errors, but made some vital saves to keep us in games including the play off final. We could do a lot worse, and if we move him on, i suspect we will.